For those of you who follow me, you may have seen a thing pop up from time to time, either on my page or another, talking about a "Mary's Mini".
So what exactly IS this Mary's Mini you ask? I wrote this post to not only answer that question, but to also give you reasons you might want to do it yourself, and more importantly - HOW to do it if you choose.
WHAT Is A Mary's Mini ?
Many of us who are plant-based, follow the teachings and guidance of Dr. John McDougall. And while his program is more of a lifestyle change than a diet - many people over the years have asked specifically for a short-term diet - just to lose a little weight healthily - but quickly.
So the good Doc, along with his wife Mary came up with this temporary 10-day diet they call - Mary's Mini.
It's a diet where you choose a starch, and then focus each and every meal for 10 straight days around that specific starch. You can choose potatoes, sweet potatoes, or even a whole grain like brown rice or quinoa, but once you choose - that is the starch you're stuck with for the duration. You then add green & yellow non-starchy vegetables as side dishes and eat until you are comfortably full.
The idea is to make the next 10 days SO boring and monotonous, that we only eat when we are actually hungry. So if you choose potatoes as your starch, I hope you really like potatoes.
WHY Would You Choose A Mary's Mini?
I know, you're thinking "Chuck, that's the nuttiest thing I've ever heard". WHY on earth would anyone want to do this?
Well, let's look at it for a minute. Whole, starchy foods, like potatoes, sweet potatoes, etc actually have all the macro and micronutrients you need. So you could theoretically live on just those alone and be perfectly fine for 10 days.
I know it doesn't sound very appealing. In fact, it sounds downright monotonous and boring as hell. But that's the whole point!
So often we eat because we're bored, or we eat because we're stressed, or we eat to feel accepted while hanging out with our friends. But are we really hungry? While doing this mini diet, if you think you're hungry - and the only thing available is another potato - you might just realize you're not THAT hungry after all!
So you naturally eat less, and you lose weight. As a bonus, you might just lose some cravings you've had, AND retrain your taste buds to eat healthier foods.
HOW To Do a Mary's Mini
So now that we've covered the WHAT and the WHY, let's talk about the HOW.
Dr. McDougall introduced this diet in his June 2006 Newsletter, and then provided a follow-up in his July 2006 Newsletter.
Naturally, the rules have been tweaked a little over the years, and so the most recent information from John and Mary themselves come from this Webinar that was held in 2016.
Below I will post all the notes I have to date which were graciously provided by the good folks at the Mary's Mini for McDougall Followers Facebook Group (another excellent resource)
Rules for Mary's Mini
1. Pick a Starch
- potatoes
- sweet potatoes
- any other root veggie (except carrots, beets, turnip, daikon, and salsify)
- corn
- winter squash like acorn
- whole grains
2. One starch ONLY is used for the next 10 days
- (potatoes OR sweet potatoes OR rice OR quinoa OR any starch - except beans)
- No switching back and forth
- There is no limit on portion size.
- Eat to satiation, not stuffed.
- If your starch is potato and you want a snack, have a potato!
2. Add some SIMPLE non-starchy veggies
- green beans, salad greens, cabbage, broccoli, cauliflower, carrots, celery, asparagus, peas, onions, garlic, mushrooms, etc.
- but nothing fancy like artichoke hearts
- If your chosen starch is a grain:
- you absolutely NEED to add some non-starchy veggies for Vitamin A & C.
3. Allowed condiments:
- veggie broth
- salsa
- mustard
- ketchup
- sriracha
- hot sauce
- nutritional yeast
- soy sauce
4. Foods NOT allowed
- any fruit (Dr. McDougall says “fruit is not your best friend for weight loss” because it tastes good and leads to overeating)
- processed sugar or substitutes
- processed grains like bread/crackers
- gravies/sauces with flour (one exception to 'no flour' is if you are doing a corn Mini, in which case polenta and corn tortillas are OK)
- beans/lentils
- nuts or nut butters
- avocado
- coconut
- chocolate
- alcohol
- tofu
- oil of any kind (coconut, avocado, olive, canola, etc)
That is the Mary's Mini - in a nutshell. I encourage you to read the newsletters and watch the webinar to fully understand the hows and whys of this program. And by all means, also join the Facebook Group I mentioned as they will also have a ton of information for you.
Does it work?
I'm on Day 5 and have already lost 5 pounds - so yes it does work. My cravings are slowly going away, my clothes fit better, and I am actually excited to go down a size in jeans for the first time in a VERY long time. You can read about all our successes in my own Brand New Vegan Community Group.
Is it boring? Yes, but that's the point.
Still, I have many potato recipes that can be adapted, so it's not TOO bad.
Questions? Leave them in the comments below and I'll try my best to answer them.
Good luck!
TK
I cooked a half a large cabbage and about 5 cut up yukon gold potatoes in my instant pot with a cup of water. I added some garkic salt and pepper. Cooked for 3 minutes. So good.
Evelyn Norwood
Thank you. Will try this for lunch or dinner!
Julie Robinson
I’m about to start a Mary’s Mini (going for a month) and I’m thinking potatoes will be the easiest. How long did you cook the potatoes with cabbage?
Niki Stevens
Great article!! I think it would be good to add 'oil' on your quick list of prohibited foods, just to reinforce that rule to people who may not be entirely up to speed on the McDougall plan. Thanks, Chuck! Very helpful!
Mel
It is there
Noelle Pion
Eating a diet based around potatoes sounds wonderful. I'd give it a try, if only to prove to people that potatoes don't make you gain weight... unless you slather them in butter and cream!
Lesley
I like the sound of Mary’s Mini but can I drink coffee or tea (black of course) whilst on this?
Chuck Underwood
I would day it's probably frowned on - but I did have my 1 cup of coffee every day.
Sarah
And I have to have cream---but that's just me. Some rules we get to make.
Jeanette Connor
Yippi
Laura
What about mushrooms? Onions? And I’m guessing aquafaba is a no...?
What do you suggest for salad dressings?
Chuck Underwood
Aquafaba is a no. Onions, mushrooms, sure - just make potatoes the main meal. As for dressings - I use Maple Grove Farms Fat-Free Dressings, or you can use Esselstyn's 321 Dressing.
Eileen
Try Waldenfarms dressings/creamers. They have no fat, no calories and no sugar.
Laura Elvin
Ew... no. Walden Farms dressings are loaded with processed material and worse, sucrolose.
Evelyn
I thought you could only eat "green" vegetables with the starch.
Chuck Underwood
He says green and yellow..... it's my understanding that means any vegetable that is not already a starch, with the exception of the fattier fruits and veggies like Avocado.
Allan Blackford
I was looking at the McDougal site on Mary's Mini. It says that a person can choose more than one starch, presumably not at the same time, in the same meal. But, I was curious why you, and others, limit themselves to just one starch? "Which starches are your favorites? Potatoes, sweet potatoes, winter squash, corn, beans, rice? Choose one or several to form the centerpiece of your diet.",
Chuck Underwood
I think you're mixing up the regular McDougall Plan with the Mary's Mini. Watch the webinar and read the 2 newsletters carefully, one starch for the duration of the mini.
Amelia
The 321 dressing has maple syrup, though; I thought that was off the list? Or is maple syrup not considered a processed sugar?
Courtney
How is it processed? 100% organic maple syrup...it’s 1 ingredient.
RachelB
Maple syrup is boiled tree sap. It's processed via concentration, just like cane sugar is concentrated (dried) juice of the sugar cane plant.
I still use maple syrup, though. It's tasty. 🙂
Jan
Salsa makes a good salad dressing.
Will Shattuck
Oil and vinegar are my go to for dressings
Sue
what about breakfast? Same thing as lunch and dinner??
Chuck Underwood
Hashbrown for breakfast, baked for lunch, mashed for dinner - whatever you like!
Cathy
I see salsa on the list, so does that mean that tomatoes are allowed? Also, what did you use to mash with your potatoes?
Chuck Underwood
Tomatoes are allowed yes. I used a little potato water to mash my potatoes, with garlic.
Ellen Fife
Where do you get protein
Chuck Underwood
All plant foods have all the Amino Acids we need. Our bodies will then assemble them into all the protein we need. There is no such thing as protein deficiency. How many people have you ever known to be treated in the hospital for protein deficiency? It's more like we have too MUCH protein. I recommend a very good book by Dr Garth Davis called Proteinaholic.
Mike
So what about basic spices during a Mary's mini? For example, I make a mean channa masala. So I just replace the chickpeas with potato cubes and add cauliflower and thinly chopped cabbage. Make a gravy using spices, tomato and water. Seems in like with these "rules". I don't see why the diet has to be boring if you're eating what is required. Your insight would be appreciated.
Natalia
Quick question.. without having read more about the weight loss program, I’m wondering if you do it for multiple weeks but switch up the starch. So if I did let’s say potatoes for the first 10 days, then quinoa the next 10. Or would that not work? I’m also wondering how the transition works going back to normal plant based diet, and if the pounds stay off. I will read and check out all ththe links you post, I guess I’m just looking for a quick answer for now.
Chuck Underwood
If you want to follow Dr. McDougall and his Starch Solution, it goes like this. The 10 day 'diet' (Mary's Mini) is just ONE starch for 10 days. He also has a "Maximum Weight Loss" (MWL) program that is good to transition to afterwards, if you want to continue losing weight (although much slower) and this is where you would add in other starches. The original McDougall Plan would then be used for maintenance, and this is where you would add in higher fat foods like an occasional avocado, handful of nuts, etc. Hope this helps.
Natalia
Thank you!
Julie
Would you mind posting exactly what you ate each day? Like, Day 1: Breakfast: Hash browns Lunch: Baked potato, etc... This would just help me out tremendously when I'm hungry and trying to figure out what to eat, lol 🙂 I'd greatly appreciate it! And congrats on your weight loss, that is awesome!!
Ronda
I I would love to see what your daily meals were. Looking for a quick fix also.
Pst
Ok-- didn't finish my full comment previously but-- we started a potato MM and fell off about 3-4 days in. ? I am thinking a bit more forethought and planning may increase our odds of success, so I think I will put together a 10day Meal Plan; batch as much as possible, and TRY to keep "grab it quick" junk out of the house. SO, I trolling recipes to KISS, and will let you know how it goes! I think I'll shoot for starting tomorrow, September 20, 2019.
Oh, and the MM was not a failure. .. four pounds down.
Joysan
I see red wine vinegar is not listed on the condiments list. Is it allowed?
Chuck Underwood
Yes!
Melody
Recipes olease
Chuck Underwood
I have an entire section dedicated to Mary's Mini - look under Recipes.
Janelle
All of your information is so helpful! Thanks Chuck!!
Ellen Fife
Can you use wild rice for the starch as I just cooked a bunch
Miss Lorelei
Hi, where do chick peas fall into this?
Chuck Underwood
They are a legume - so not allowed
Lorraine
AaCan u use aged balsamic vinegar.?
Chuck Underwood
yes!
Andrea
I know that fruit isn't allowed but can I squeeze a little lemon juice on my sweet potatoes?
Chuck Underwood
I really do not see the harm. Sure.
Julie Spears
Well, after seeing your email about Mary's Mini, I was mildly curious as my weight loss has stalled. I've been thinking about it for a couple of weeks now, reading and researching, and think I'm ready to give it a try. So even though I've had my morning berry bowl, I will start with lunch today. Perhaps a baked or steamed potato with some homemade marinara sauce on it. For supper, I'll try mashed potatoes and a gravy made with some onions, mushrooms, spices and some mashed potatoes to thicken. Wish me luck. I still need to lose 20 more pounds.
Ruby Barraza
Have you lost weight?! How long did you do it for?
Ellen Fife
What can you use for salad dressing. I mixed balsamic and mustard and left out the maple syrup as per mary’s 321 recipe
Samara Al-Ahmar
What about fresh herbs, lemon/lime juice?
Chuck Underwood
Absolutely
Nicole
If you choose potatoes for your starch, can you use potato flour/starch?
Chuck Underwood
Just remember when you remove the water, you are increasing a foods calorie density. And, it is now highly processed. Be careful.
Brian Riggle
are bell (red/yellow/green) peppers allowed on the Mini ?
Chuck Underwood
Absolutely
Pam
Is water the only allowed beverage?
What about herbal tea?
Chuck Underwood
Yes, herbal tea is fine too.
Wendy
Hello! I read both newsletters and didn't see anywhere that beans are not allowed. She states that if you use beans as your starch you HAVE to add some fruit and/or green and yellow vegetables. So I'm wondering why you list that beans/legumes are off limits? Did I miss something? Where is this information listed that beans aren't allowed? Thank you for your time in this. Have a wonderful day!
Chuck Underwood
Realize both newsletters are pretty old - which is why I also included the newer video. The video is where Dr. McD says no beans - as you would get way too much protein.
Brandy
What ketchup are you referring too?? There is so much sugar and bad stuff in ketchup that I can't image that is allowed. Normally I eat Organicsville ketchup made with Agave syrup. would that work? Everything else was very clear for me. Thanks
Chuck Underwood
All I know is that it is approved by the McDs. Sounds like you picked a healthy one to use.
Christina
Where are you finding Maple Grove locally? Safeway just discontinued them over by me. Thanks
Laura
How do I search your recipes for the Mary’s Mini compliant ones?
Chuck Underwood
Go to my Recipe Index in the Menu on top. Look for Marys Mini Recipes..... or use the search box across the very top of the page.
Melissa
Can the starch vegetable be plantains?
Chuck Underwood
You really want to eat those 3x a day for 10 days in a row? I'm not really sure, to be honest. Since it's so closely related to a fruit I'm inclined to say no.
Marianne Gosling
I am excited to give this a try. I am German and to loose weight on potatoes? Wonderful!!! This is such good news.
Lynn
Can this be adapted for non vegans?
Chuck Underwood
I really don't think so. The idea is to reset your taste buds and sustain yourself on mostly starch.
Cathy
Can you have miso with the potato's, for a sauce/btot/gravy?
Chuck Underwood
Since miso is soybean-based, which has a fair amount of fat - I would think not.
Lynn
Two questions:
1. Can I use gravy if I make it with potato flour/starch?
2. Can I use the above to make your Crispy Oven Baked Fries?
Chuck Underwood
My cheese sauce I consider legal because it's made with just potatoes and carrots. But the gravy I don't know, as I have been told even potato starch is not allowed. I know some people do it anyway, so I would ay it's up to you. If you do and your weight loss stalls - then maybe try again without it.
Mariels
I’m starting today with acorn squash!!What about ginger and pickle ginger?
Chuck Underwood
Sure!
Michelle K.
This is my first day of my MM. Quite frankly, I feel awful. I had hashbrown for breakfast, baby Yukons and broccoli for lunch. I am nauseated and sick to my stomach. I'm definitely not hungry, I just feel horrible. If this doesn't pass, I won't make it. 🙁
Barbara
I am curious as to what drinks are aloud?
Chuck Underwood
Water.
Mike
I’m 3 days in on my Mary’s Mini and my scale hasn’t budged a single ounce. Very frustrating because I eat until full (potatoes and some form of greens) 3 meals a day. Snacks (rare) are just cold, boiled potatoes with a little salt or ketchup. Any advice? I’m hungry all the time!
Chuck Underwood
Put away the scales until the end of the 10 days. Everyone's gut biome is different and it takes time for the body to adjust.
Mike
Thanks Chuck. Been WFPB for almost two years. I should be adjusted already. LOL
But , I’ll give it time and see.
mariette Vautour
Is saurkraut allowed on Mary's Mini?
Chuck Underwood
It's just cabbage, so I don't know why not. Sure.
inge Reissenzahn
I'm day 9 with potatoes as my chosen starch, didn't think I could face another potato come day 4 but now it's become so much of my routine, I am stressing about what to do post 10 day...just resume normal WFPB routine? Could one look at doing a 10 day once a month? Thanks for any input in this regard
Chuck Underwood
Dr McDougall also has a Maximum Weight Loss Diet - which is similar to a Mary's Mini but a lot less restrictive. I would look into this for maintenance.
Kathryn Gannon
Why is bread not allowed?
Chuck Underwood
Because it is processed, usually contains oil, and can defeat the purpose of a Mini - which is to reset your taste buds.
Tami
Are you certain that green peas are allowed? They are so much higher in carbs and calories? Also, is salsa is allowed, then what about fat free marinara? Great article thanks for explaining and posting the updated version.
Chuck Underwood
Yes - peas are allowed. Mary McDougall said so herself in the Webinar I linked to in the post.
Tami
Should read IF salsa .
Sonja
I was wondering if it’s okay on Mary’s Mini to use almond milk in mashed potatoes. I see no nuts or nut butters, but didn’t specify about nut milks.
Chuck Underwood
Nut milks are also to be avoided.
Sandra White
A carton of Almond milk only has 4 almond total in the carton...so wonder if it would really hurt...only 1 almond per 8 oz cup
PJ
Can you choose oatmeal as my starch.
Chuck Underwood
You can.... but do you really want to eat oats? 3x a day for 10 days straight?
Mg
What about raw honey
Chuck Underwood
Sorry, but no.
Pamela
Is chewing gum allowed? It is sugarfree. I tend to get a piece of gum and chew it for hours. Chewing helps me with the ringing in my ears. Basically it helps me ignore it. I could chew one piece of gum all day long.
Chuck Underwood
Sure
Sheryl
Hi Chuck,
Curios as to why you use Panko crumbs in this recipe. I thought bread was off limits in the MM. Please explain. These crinkle potatoes look delicious! thanks. Sheryl
Chuck Underwood
Leave them out for a MM
Genny Teixeira
Would eggplant and tomatoes be acceptable?
Chuck Underwood
Yes
Angela
I thought peas were a “bean” and therefore considered a starch??? Are they allowed and if so, how about edamame? Thanks!
Chuck Underwood
Peas - yes. Soybeans - or any soy - no.
JULIE
Can I use nutritional yeast
Chuck Underwood
Sure
Tina
Chuck, thank you for posting this. I have been frustrated with slow weight gain and found it very difficult to lose any weight. I went on the potato MM for 4 days and lost 4 pounds. Eating potatoes are very satisfying and filling for me. Perhaps if others don't have success with them another starch may be better. Thanks again.
Julie Broderick
Mary says you can eat peas. Does that also mean you can eat splits
Chuck Underwood
Spit peas are a legume - and I think the answer is no legumes or beans during the 10 day Mini.
Tamara
Can season salt be used?
Galina
Are peas considered a green vegetable and corn a starch? If so, is it acceptable to eat corn and peas for 10 days? I can certainly eat corn and green peas all day, so 3x 10 days should not be a problem at all. Otherwise my preferred grain is oats, but I like it sweet with fruit or with nut or soy milk and that's off-limit.for MM.
Thank you
Chuck Underwood
Peas are fine.
Rebecca S.
Do I have to stick with one type of potato if I am not using sweet Potatoes, or can I alternate between them? (i.e. russet, yellow, red, purple)
Chuck Underwood
You can alternate.
Maggie
great info...thanks...can I eat polenta as well if I choose to eat corn on the cob for the 10 days?
Erin
Yes! You can also have corn tortillas on a corn mini.
Kristy
Can you eat sauerkraut on a Mary’s mini? What about red peppers? Thanks!
Chuck Underwood
Yes!
Amelia
Thank you for all the information!!! Since stevia is a green plant, is that acceptable to use?
Rebecca
Is miso allowed? I’m wondering if your sweet potato soup with miso would be mini compliant
kim
Can I Use Pam or other cooking spray on my potatoes?
Chuck Underwood
No - absolutely not.
Heather
After completing the Marys mini for ten days - how long do you wait to start over again please?
Chuck Underwood
Some people have stayed on longer than 10 days. Some do it once a month. It's really up to you. Or you can simply ease into his Maximum Weight Loss program, which allows a few more foods than the mini
Ming
Hi Chuck. I was only on day two of the Mary's Mini, but I really wanted mushroom gravy on my mashed potatoes. So I improvised and came up with a way to make it compliant. I wanted to share this with you since you are the recipe creator and you might be able to use the idea to come up with something much better than what I threw together! I water sauteed mushrooms, garlic, and onions, added veggie broth and of the liquid from boiling the potatoes to make mashed potatoes, seasoned with herbs, soy sauce and pepper, then I thickened it with some of the mashed potatoes themselves. I had overcooked the potatoes, so they were pretty smooth, but next time I'll blend them up a bit first. I added the mashed potatoes spoonful by spoonful until the sauce got thick (probably about 3/4 cup of potatoes), and then I decided to puree about a third of the gravy in my vitamix, and added it back in. The result was a thick, rich, almost creamy gravy with no flour, no nut milk, nothing not allowed! I enjoyed it on mashed potatoes that night, and on baked potatoes the following day!
Vicki thompson
So I guess Edamame it’s probably not good and Mary’s mini diet
Daniela Perner
You are such a sweet soul Chuck! I follow your receipes because of my health condition and it works very well. And now you even share your receipes for MM to make it all that easy for us? And they all sound delicious?! I will try itvout. Not to lose weight but just to see how 10 days of potatos work. Im german so you know we love our Kartoffelsalat haha thank you!
Wallace
Hi Brand New Vegan!
I am a 350+ pound man who has had great success with the Mary's Mini Diet, and I want to thank you for your simple and concise explanation!
I remember searching the web and getting confused on the various aspects of the diet until I came upon your site.
I credit your great explanation with helping me to get started.
Thanks so much!
-Wallace
bodywhittle.com/day0003
Amelia
Thank you for all of this information!!! If corn is the starch I choose, does that mean I can have corn starch (in extreme moderation, like, to thicken a mushroom gravy) and popcorn? I would think yes but I figured best to clarify because I could eat popcorn all day.
Donna
Can we have pickles?
Mady
Can I do this diet more than 10 days ?